Reporting, Appraising, and Integrating Data On Genotype Prevalence and Gene-Disease Associations Table

arrow

back to report

TABLE 1: Proposed checklist for reporting and appraising studies of genotype prevalence and gene-disease associations
Item to be specified Details by type of study
Genotype prevalence Gene-disease associations
Purpose of study
Yes
Detect associations or estimate magnitude of association
Analytic validity of genotyping
Types of samples used
Yes
For cases and for controls
Timing of sample collection and analysis, by study group*
Ethnic group†
Cases vs. controls†
Success rate in extracting DNA, by study group*
Ethnic group†
Cases vs. controls†
Definition of the genotype(s) investigated; when there are multiple alleles, those tested for should be specified
Yes
Yes
Genotyping method used (reference; for polymerase chain reaction methods—primer sequences,* thermocyle profile,* no. of cycles*)
Yes
Yes
Percentage of potentially eligible subjects for whom valid genotypic data were obtained, by study group
Ethnic group†
Cases vs. controls†
If pooling was used, strategy for pooling of specimens from cases and controls
Yes
Quality control measures*
Yes
Including blinding of
laboratory staff
Degree of reproducibility between quality control replicates
Yes
Yes
Samples from each group of subjects compared (e.g., cases and controls) included in each batch analyzed*
Yes
Selection of study subjects
Geographic area from which subjects were recruited
Yes
Yes
The recruitment period
Yes
Yes
Recruitment methods for subjects whose genotypes were determined, such as random population-based sampling, blood donors, and hospitalized subjects with reasons for hospitalization
Yes
Controls†
Definition of cases and method of ascertainment
Yes
No. of cases recruited from families and methods used to account for related subjects
Yes
Exclusion criteria for cases and controls
Yes
Recruitment rates
Where possible by sex, age, and ethnic group
For cases and controls
Mean age and standard deviation or age range of study subjects, and the distribution by sex
Yes
For cases and controls
If the subjects were controls from a case-control study, information on the disease under investigation and any matching criteria such as age, gender, and/or risk factor levels
Yes
Ethnic group of study subjects

Yes

Similarity of sociodemographic (or other) characteristics of subjects for whom valid genotypic data were obtained with characteristics of subjects for whom such data were not obtained*
Yes
Steps taken to ensure that controls are noncases*
Yes
Confounding, including population stratification
Design
Yes
If other than a case-family control design, matching for ethnicity or adjustment for ethnicity in analysis
Yes
Potential correlates of the genotype identified and taken into consideration in design or analysis
Yes
Statistical issues
Distinguish clearly a priori hypotheses and hypotheses generated
Yes
If haplotypes used, specify how these were constructed
Yes
Yes
No. of subjects included in the analysis
Yes
Yes
Method of analysis, with reference, and software used to do this
Yes
Confidence intervals
Of genotype frequency
Of measures of association with the genotype
Assessment of goodness-of-fit of the model used*
Yes

* Additional information recorded (ideally in Web-based methods register) but not necessarily presented in journal article.
† For example.

 Top of Page